| Name | LaCrosse | Chicago |
| Aaron Vanover | Unsure | No |
| Al Kent | Yes | Yes |
| Andrew Hill | Yes | No |
| Andrew Irving | Yes | Yes |
| Benoit Morin | Unsure | No |
| Bill McCafferty | Yes | Yes |
| Bobby Bonslater | Yes | Yes |
| Brad Caraway | Yes | No |
| Brandon Smith | Unsure | Yes |
| Brian Parker | Unsure | No |
| Cameron Kaszas | Yes | No |
| Chad Duggan | No | Unsure |
| Chad Gulick | Yes | No |
| Chris Bratz | Yes | No |
| Chris holland | Unsure | Unsure |
| Chris Martingilio | Yes | No |
| Chris Reott | Yes | Yes |
| Christopher McCafferty | No | Unsure |
| Craig Mason | Yes | Yes |
| Dale Koebke | Yes | No |
| Dan Maxwell | Yes | No |
| David Hochstetter | Unsure | Unsure |
| David Koelz | Yes | Unsure |
| David Lee | Yes | Unsure |
| David Ludwick | Yes | No |
| David Newcomb | Unsure | No |
| Duane DrWire (DD) | Unsure | No |
| Flip Robison | Yes | No |
| Frank Gonzales | Yes | Unsure |
| Frank Sloan | Yes | No |
| Frank Wateska | Yes | Yes |
| Frederick Omega Pye | Yes | Yes |
| Gary McNitt | Yes | No |
| Jack Reese | Yes | No |
| Jeff Rowland | Yes | Unsure |
| Jeff Spanos | Unsure | No |
| Jerry (Jay) Buhrow | Yes | Unsure |
| Jim Schmelzer | Yes | No |
| Jimmer Dudley | Yes | No |
| Joe Itkor | Unsure | No |
| Joel Zapata | Unsure | No |
| Joey B. Banks | Yes | Yes |
| John D'Amico | Yes | No |
| John Owens | Yes | Yes |
| John Zamorski | Yes | No |
| Jon Newcomb | Yes | No |
| Jon Schrack | Yes | No |
| Jordan Delk | Unsure | Yes |
| Josh Forbord | Unsure | Unsure |
| Keith Johnson | Unsure | No |
| Kenny Miller | Unsure | Unsure |
| Kent Eversmeyer | Yes | Yes |
| Kevin Deisher | Unsure | No |
| Kevin Taylor | Unsure | Unsure |
| Kurt Wouters | Yes | Yes |
| Kurtis Polishinski | Yes | No |
| Lee Williams | Unsure | No |
| Marco Iannelli | Yes | No |
| Mark Buchwalder | Unsure | Yes |
| Mark Herman | Unsure | No |
| Marshall Smith | Unsure | No |
| Matthew Foster | Unsure | No |
| Mike Ausman | Yes | No |
| Mike Cegelski | Yes | Unsure |
| Mike Garvin | Unsure | No |
| Mike Robinson | Unsure | No |
| Mitch Haycock | Yes | Unsure |
| Paul Bailey | Yes | No |
| Randy Ferrie | Yes | Unsure |
| Rick Dunlevy | Yes | No |
| Rick Kaufhold | Unsure | No |
| Robert Elliott | Yes | Yes |
| Ryan Bickett | Unsure | No |
| Scott Pearson | Yes | Yes |
| Shaun Owens | Unsure | No |
| Stanley Winston | Unsure | Unsure |
| Steve Boulka | Yes | No |
| Tim Barstow | Unsure | Unsure |
| Tom McInvaille | Yes | Yes |
| Tommy Mitchell | Yes | Unsure |
| Tony Reilly | Yes | Unsure |
| Wayne Reynols | Yes | No |
| William J Veerhusen | Unsure | No |
| Total | Total LaCrosse | Total Chicago |
| YES | LaCrosse 59 | Chicago 17 |
| UNSURE | LaCrosse 29 | Chicago 19 |
| NO | LaCrosse 2 | Chicago 47 |
*Numbers as of 10/12/2021